Newfoundland’s Oldest Home: DeMouth-Snyder House

peter snyder house newfoundland, nj

Perhaps the oldest home still standing in Newfoundland is located on Green Pond Road. The original section of the house was erected in 1732 by a member of the DeMouth (DeMont) family. There is a strong possibility that the family had originally built a log cabin before constructing the substantial stone cottage. In that era, the family would have shared the land with tribes associated with the Lenni Lenape Indians.

For years the home was referred to as the “Stone Cottage” and there must have been quite a settlement in Newfoundland prior to 1730, or a structure of that kind would not have been undertaken.

These lands would be inherited by the wife of Peter Snyder, who expanded the house in 1773. Several generations later, the Cole, Davenport, Brown, Eckhart and Kanouse families would emigrate to Newfoundland from England & Germany. A sister of Leonard Cole married Israel Holley and verbal history in 1902 suggested that the Indians carried away one of their children, who grew up with the local tribe.

The local 19th century historian, J.P. Crayon reasoned that Dutch settlers came to Newfoundland as early as 1715 because of the existence of records that indicated that Dutch ministers were dispatched to Newfoundland and held services throughout the region. Those same ministers would eventually organize the First Baptist Church of Newfoundland and The Presbyterian Church of Oak Ridge.

The towns of Clinton and Charlotteburg would also be included on the circuit where ministers would visit. The village of Clinton derived its name from Sir Henry Clinton (c. 1738-1795) who was a British general in the American Revolutionary War and a veteran of the French and Indian War.

The Town of Charlotteburg was named after Charlotte of Mecklenburg-Strelitz (Sophia Charlotte; 1744 – 1818) who was the wife of King George III. She was Queen of Great Britain and Ireland from her marriage from 1761 until 1818. A Revolutionary War Furnace still remains submerged under the Charlotteburg Reservoir which had been built in 1768 and was operated by Hessian soldiers. Many of these Hessians remained in the area after the war and settled at Macopin, where they established the first Catholic Church in New Jersey that would become St. Joseph’s.

You may also like


    1. Yes, it is still standing and hopefully will be restored. Unfortunately, it has become a party house for kids who have broken and couldn’t resist doing damage to the structure.

  1. I am a descendant of the Israel Holley named in the article. I live in CA but visited NJ last month. The “sister of Leonard Cole” married to Israel was Saartje Cool (changed to Sarah Cole), and they had 2 children, Elizabeth and Robert (Elizabeth apparently being the daughter that was abducted, one account says “by the Delawares”). I would very much like to know where Saartje and Israel lived and were buried. Israel apparently died in 1763 (at the age of 42, possibly as a result of the Delaware attack?)

    1. There is an unmarked cemetery between the river and railroad tracks in the oak trees. In the late 60s as a kid I could read flat grave markes that went back into the late 1700s up to later 1880s. Quite a few were soldiers from 1812 era. Most of the early ones are now buried and the remaining ones are losing their readability. I was there yesterday as I was back from west coast for my 50th class reunion. Old American Legion flags marked some graves. About 30 remain. Perhaps 30 or 40 less than when I was a kid. The old 1773 house used to have a stone carriage block out next to drive to aid getting out of tall carriages but that seemed to be gone now. A shame no efforts to preserve the oldest house in town.

  2. This cottage is on city of Newark watershed property. Sadly they are not maintaining g it and won’t allow historic groups to use it.

    The house is actually in Jefferson – Morris County.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *